Fans of the Tyneside club are more and more seeing Eddie Howe's side as a fickle companion. On their day, they can be the very entertainers, producing high-intensity performances. But, in other matches, once-dependable individuals like Sandro Tonali and others utterly fail to appear.
Compounding these problems is a second-half approach laced with a distinct streak of panic. Before their holiday fixture to Old Trafford, the statistics reveal a concerning story: the team has dropped thirteen vital Premier League leverage from leading situations this campaign and are without a clean sheet in ten consecutive matches in every tournament. Claiming a win at their famous stadium would represent only their second-ever league success on the road this season.
Conversely, defeat has only come on one occasion in their most recent six league fixtures, and despite occupying a seemingly lowly 11th position, they remain a mere six points away from the highly-prized top four. Factor in an upcoming two-part Carabao Cup last-four clash against Manchester City and a reasonable chance of progressing to the Champions League last 16, and it is easier to see the manager's guarded hope.
âOur issues aren't limited to difficulties,â said the club's boss. âWe have assets as well. I am very much half full at present. I understand others could have a opposing take, but my belief is we are improving.â
The puzzle remains: will this squad match â or perhaps surpass â the heights of the previous campaign's Wembley triumph and fifth-place finish? Juggling a congested calendar complicates.
This fatigue might explain the failure to sustain a superb first-half performance versus their London rivals, ultimately surrendering a 2-0 advantage to tie the game. Similarly, it could be the reason for a subdued performance in a damaging loss to local rivals Sunderland, where the side looked sluggish just days after a grueling Champions League excursion.
While coaching is undoubtedly the manager's specialty, the relentless schedule of two games a week football has radically cut into crucial coaching time. This slows the team's tactical adjustment to operating with summer signing their number nine up front, rather than the departed Alexander Isak. While hugely talented, the German forward has not shown the equivalent searing counter-attacking speed or relentless pressing.
In fact, the side's signature high press has at times broken down. Injuries to crucial engine Joelinton have been a factor, while high-profile signings the Swedish winger and the English midfielder have had difficulties settling since their combined ÂŁ90m+ transfers.
While a switch to a back three could theoretically benefit the team, a full-blown defensive absence list renders that difficult. First-choice full-backs will be unavailable for the next key matches, challenging the team's resilience.
At their energetic best, they look almost unplayable. The issue is sustaining that fervor for the entire match. The often-seen plan B of sitting back into a deep-lying counter-attacking formation has sometimes proven self-destructive.
âThe Chelsea game became disorganized at two-all,â admitted the coach. âHowever we were trying to win. We always go out to win.â
What seems required is a middle ground â involving better possession control, a midfield capable of slowing the pace, and a realistic readiness to occasionally accept a draw. However, a ambition to compete on every competitions is stretching limited player resources to their breaking point.
This might seem unthinkable to some, but a different approach in the cup competitions earlier could have alleviated the current fixture pile-up. Amid critical Champions League and Premier League matches on the agenda, the necessity to carefully prioritize is becoming ever more apparent.
The manager acknowledged the magnitude of the journey ahead. âWhen you're involved a club of this size, the demands are enormous. Each game is pivotal. We have work to do in the Premier League. We are in the League Cup last four, we aim to go through in the Europe and do well in the FA Cup.
âThe direction is in the right direction, but we have a great deal of improvement to do to transform into the regularly winning team we aspire to be. The ability to string together sequences of victories has eluded us so far.
âThe task is to attain those levels we are aware we're capable of. The internal belief is that the self-belief to do that is growing. But nowadays we have to prove it. It's not all doom and gloom right now, but the coming period will determine a lot.â
A passionate sports journalist with over a decade of experience covering Italian football and local Turin events.